You’ll notice there are three books missing from my reviews over the past three days – I have read them, but just couldn’t bring myself to expend any energy on writing about them: Sleeping on Jupiter is dull, The chimes is an average example of a dystopian future, and Satin island forgets that a novel has to have emotional heft as well as intellectual.
I’m still worried the Americans have invaded:
So. The shortlist. I’m surprised, slightly, that my own shortlist is actually pretty similar to the official one.
Did you ever have a family, Bill Clegg
A brief history of seven killings, Marlon James
The fishermen, Chigozie Obioma
Lila, Marilynne Robinson
The year of the runaways, Sunjeev Sahota
A little life, Hanya Yanagihara
Among those six, there are four that I would be happy to see win: James, Obioma, Sahota or Yanagihara. All are spectacularly excellent novels that deserve a wide readership, and really speak to a lot of what is going on in the world today.
But I am going to pick a winner. And I know it’s the favourite, and I know it’s an easy out, but I’m really hoping A little life gets up. I know it’s divisive, but for me, it really was the best thing on this longlist. I don’t think I’ve ever read a 700-page brick so fast, and even though it’s often melodramatic, overwrought and ridiculous, it really is, underneath all that, a book about the incredible strength love can give us if we just let it in.
And that’s it! If I remember, I’ll write a reaction post to the winner – tomorrow night, AEDST.
Wow, spot-on with your predictions, only Satin Island spoiling your perfect score (I have it on my ereader but haven’t read it yet, but I hear it is somewhat divisive).
I’ve never been good at picking shortlists, so I’m quite surprised.
Satin Island isn’t bad, but I do think it suffers a little from not being quite as emotionally engaging as it is intellectually stimulating. Your mileage may vary, of course.