The Folded Earth (2011) – Anuradha ROY

I imagine being Anuradha Roy would be a frustrating experience. No doubt people constantly think she is Arundhati Roy, and while positive comparisons may be flattering, the ineviable “I’m the other Roy” would be soul crushing. Of course, with The Folded Earth, Anuradha has beaten Arundhati for number of novels published, so that’s nice. But is this novel good enough for Anuradha to become the famous Roy? Certainly the judges of this year’s Man Asian Literary Prize think so.

An horrific event sends Maya from her life in the city to the foothills of the Himalaya, to a town called Ranikhet. Slowly, she builds a life amongst the other people already living there – from Diwan Sahib, an eccentric old academic with whom she helps organise papers; Miss Wilson, the principal of the Catholic school at which she works, and Charu, a young girl who lives in the neighbouring cottage. But life in the mountains is never as peaceful as Maya had once hoped, and a new arrival will force her to confront her past.

First things first – Roy has an excellent command of language, and her descriptions and evocations of a part of the world where few people live and where the natural world reigns supreme are gorgeous. More than anything else, this contributes to a sense of space that I felt keenly. Rainikhet, too, is brought to life with verve, and the clash of ramshakle tradition with people from new money with new ideas is highlighted in the geography of the town, complete with a little map in the front flap so you can easily follow the action.

The people that populate Ranikhet, though, are what make it what it is. This is a town full of eccentrics – starting with the old man himself, Diwan Shaib. As the stereotypical old man, he manages to yell at a lot of people, though it is clear he has a soft spot for Maya. When his nephew, Veer, comes back into town, it is clear Diwan is looking for a relation to lean on. The (and I use this term very loosely) mystery at the centre of the novel is whether Veer is simply using the old man to get at his supposed fortune, or whether he truly wants to get closer. There is also an awkward romance with Maya, and there is (again, a loose term) a twist at the end of the tale which reveals both Veer’s true intentions, as well as the discovery of a link to Maya she didn’t know existed.

I wanted to love Maya as a character, honest. Those opening pages, with her dealing with Michael’s death, and the complete rejection by her parents simply because he was Christian (an important reminder that, a lot of the time, racism goes both ways), highlight just how much potential Roy has as a writer. In many ways, you could take those opening few chapters, turn them into a short story, and have a solid, good story. Unfortunately, though, the rest of the novel fails to live up to this high standard. The plot becomes fractured, and while the majority is written in the first person, from Maya’s perspective, there are occasional jaunts into omniscient third, where we follow Charu. These are unnecessary and, in the end, jarring. There aren’t enough of these third person chapters to warrant a two narrator novel, and they stick out like a sore thumb.

Questions of love, and of female identity, are somewhere in here. Maya and Charu both fall in love with men that have the unfortunate honour of being intensely disliked by their lady friend’s parents simply because of their standing in society. For Michael, this is a question of religion, and for Charu, it is a question of employment. Apart from Maya, and one female cop, the female characters in The Folded Earth are constantly put down, highlighting the “traditional” role that women seem to play in this culture. It is up to people like Miss Wilson to educate the young women of the town, but the unfortunate political climate pits Christians against Hindus, and her work is less than admired by the external politicans blowing in.

As I said earlier, the strength of this novel is the writing itself. Anuradha Roy clearly loves language, and I love reading her language. But her characters and plot are messy, and fractured. The Folded Earth suffers from trying to be a widescreen novel in a 4:3 ratio. The vast cast of characters are never given enough room to breathe on their own, and as such the message of the book is lost. I’m not usually one to advocate longer novels, but if this were twice the size, it might be better. Alternatively, had Roy separated out her narrative strands and given them their own section, each one may have been stronger. Nevertheless, I’m curious to see what she does next.

About these ads
Tagged , ,

13 thoughts on “The Folded Earth (2011) – Anuradha ROY

  1. Sounds like a beautiful book. I had read one other review of it from someone who enjoyed it as much as you did. It sounds like it has an important message and is well written – perfect

  2. markbooks says:

    It’s interesting comparing this book to another longlistee, ‘The Good Muslim’. Where ‘The Good Muslim’ carries a much more important message about identity, religion etc, it lacks the beauty and richness of Roy’s prose. For example, you wouldn’t catch Roy describing the stench from the local leather factory simply as “overpowering”. I take your point about the “widescreen novel”. But I don’t particularly think that’s a bad thing. Anyway – what next? I recommend The Wandering Falcon, my favourite so far.

    • Matthew Todd says:

      It is an interesting companion, and reading them one after another was a good exercise, I think. It didn’t help that both of the main characters were young women called Maya who had similar character arcs.

      You’re right – Roy is the better stylist, hands down, and it really brings the novel to a much better level than I think The Good Muslim ever achieves. But maybe Anam’s message is more important? No doubt there’s an entire debate to be had about which of those points is more important…

      As for what’s next – I’ve just finished 1Q84, and then I’m having a short break from the longlist. I need to read something completely different to cleanse my palate before I hit up the second half.

  3. Ah, am halfway through this, Matt, and have somewhat mixed feelings though am enjoying it overall. Will read your review properly when I’ve finished it and comment then.

    • Have now finished it … took me a while with all the Xmas activity going on … but I basically agree with you now I come back and read your review. I’d read her again (probably).

  4. [...] – Amitav GHOSH (Lisa) 1Q84 – Haruki MURAKAMI The Folded Earth – Anuradha ROY (Me) Please Look After Mother – Kyung-Sook SHIN (Me; Stu) The Valley of Masks – Tarun J [...]

  5. [...] Roy’s The folded earth (India) by Matt of A Novel Approach. He’s impressed, with [...]

  6. [...] review of The Folded Earth by Anuradha Roy.  View it here, and (if you haven’t already, also check out Matt’s at A Novel [...]

  7. Tony says:

    Looks like there’s a fair consensus here, which is a pity as it sounds interesting.

  8. [...] GHOSH (Lisa; Mark) 1Q84 – Haruki MURAKAMI (Me; Lisa) The Folded Earth – Anuradha ROY (Me; Fay; Sue; Mark) Please Look After Mother – Kyung-Sook SHIN (Me; Lisa; Mark; Stu) The Valley [...]

  9. [...] of Smoke – Amitav GHOSH The Folded Earth – Anuradha ROY Please Look After Mother – SHIN Kyung-sook The Valley of Masks – Tarun J. TEJPAL Dream [...]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: